I always wondered why old movies are rated so high on IMDb. For example, 12 Angry Men (1954) with just ~900K votes ranks about as high as Inception (2010) with ~2M votes. Few people I know have seen 12 Angry Men. So where does this high rating come from? My theories were: Old movies really are that good. IMDb’s algorithm is biased towards old movies. People remember older movies fondly. Actually, it’s none of these. It’s selection bias. ...