Comments on: Classical Ilayaraja 13 http://www.s-anand.net/blog/classical-ilayaraja-13/ Technology, business and fun Fri, 12 Mar 2010 16:33:50 +0000 http://wordpress.org/?v=2.9.2 hourly 1 By: simran http://www.s-anand.net/blog/classical-ilayaraja-13/comment-page-1/#comment-3972 simran Fri, 12 Feb 2010 07:15:48 +0000 http://localhost/blog/classical-ilayaraja-13/#comment-3972 It seems all composers borrow. Puccini borrowed from earlier composers, Lloyd Webber borrowed from him and later worked with AR who borrowed from other earlier Indian composers! It's just one long chain of borrowing! It seems all composers borrow. Puccini borrowed from earlier composers, Lloyd Webber borrowed from him and later worked with AR who borrowed from other earlier Indian composers! It’s just one long chain of borrowing!

]]> By: Bhaskaran http://www.s-anand.net/blog/classical-ilayaraja-13/comment-page-1/#comment-3425 Bhaskaran Thu, 25 Jun 2009 08:06:53 +0000 http://localhost/blog/classical-ilayaraja-13/#comment-3425 Hi all, There is no musician in world without inspiration. We should Realize this.Even mozart n beethoven should hav got inspired sum where and if u clearly notice in mozart's music...in many place he himself got inspired in his music and used a repeated peices many places... In same way Ilayaraja,Rehman, gets inspiration with some with music.. Without this no musician could come up..But there is huge difference between copying and inspiring...Comparing to others theirs inspiration level is low. But Ilayaraja Purely, greatly, gives all of music upto his traditional way...And the arrangement of instruments too same...Purely tamil cultured music...Thats the only Reason he his king of south...King of Music...King of Creativity...Musicians may realize how he gives importance to songs, bg's going back songs...Re recordings....Similarity will be ther in all kind of music...If u ask Tamil traditional musicians to compose in purely western style...So he starts lisenting western to get sum idea...Without that how can it Happen. So obviously inspiration starts over ther.... Hi all, There is no musician in world without inspiration.
We should Realize this.Even mozart n beethoven should hav got inspired sum where and if u clearly notice in mozart’s music…in many place he himself got inspired in his music and used a repeated peices many places…
In same way Ilayaraja,Rehman, gets inspiration with some with music..
Without this no musician could come up..But there is huge difference between copying and inspiring…Comparing to others theirs inspiration level is low. But Ilayaraja Purely, greatly, gives all of music upto his traditional way…And the arrangement of instruments too same…Purely tamil cultured music…Thats the only Reason he his king of south…King of Music…King of Creativity…Musicians may realize how he gives importance to songs, bg’s going back songs…Re recordings….Similarity will be ther in all kind of music…If u ask Tamil traditional musicians to compose in purely western style…So he starts lisenting western to get sum idea…Without that how can it Happen. So obviously inspiration starts over ther….

]]> By: Naveen Kumar http://www.s-anand.net/blog/classical-ilayaraja-13/comment-page-1/#comment-3376 Naveen Kumar Sun, 07 Jun 2009 06:47:51 +0000 http://localhost/blog/classical-ilayaraja-13/#comment-3376 Every musical instrument have some specific way and methods to play it. It may sound similar if they are played as prescribed method. So, My point is, because of same sound of the music we should not come to the conclusion that it is copied. Best example of copy is a song from the recent movie "Kathalin vilunthen" - "Unakenna naan" which is litrally copied from "Rihana - Unfaithfull". But Raja & Rahaman's composition may not look like that. Sometimes it may sound similar but if you feel the music you can get the diffrence.In "Margali poove" it is the usage of the tune it is not copied, As in "theepidika" from "Arinthul Ariyamalum". So you guys don't spoil the name of the legends. Don't listen to music the rather feel the music then, you may know the talant of these lengends. Every musical instrument have some specific way and methods to play it. It may sound similar if they are played as prescribed method. So, My point is, because of same sound of the music we should not come to the conclusion that it is copied. Best example of copy is a song from the recent movie “Kathalin vilunthen” – “Unakenna naan” which is litrally copied from “Rihana – Unfaithfull”. But Raja & Rahaman’s composition may not look like that. Sometimes it may sound similar but if you feel the music you can get the diffrence.In “Margali poove” it is the usage of the tune it is not copied, As in “theepidika” from “Arinthul Ariyamalum”. So you guys don’t spoil the name of the legends. Don’t listen to music the rather feel the music then, you may know the talant of these lengends.

]]> By: Venkat http://www.s-anand.net/blog/classical-ilayaraja-13/comment-page-1/#comment-3268 Venkat Tue, 28 Apr 2009 15:19:38 +0000 http://localhost/blog/classical-ilayaraja-13/#comment-3268 Srinivasan's comment on IR about "Le Cocou" is incorrect. They are diffrent ragas with not much similarties. Dr. Ramakrishnan's article is not about knocking one music director over other but it is about dissecting music with primary importance to IR style of music. I am incompetant to comment on the intricacies of the articles but had a great time reading them. Srinivasan’s comment on IR about “Le Cocou” is incorrect. They are diffrent ragas with not much similarties.

Dr. Ramakrishnan’s article is not about knocking one music director over other but it is about dissecting music with primary importance to IR style of music. I am incompetant to comment on the intricacies of the articles but had a great time reading them.

]]> By: sRIDHAR http://www.s-anand.net/blog/classical-ilayaraja-13/comment-page-1/#comment-346 sRIDHAR Sun, 18 Mar 2007 15:35:55 +0000 http://localhost/blog/classical-ilayaraja-13/#comment-346 excellent work pl . go on doing some more!1KEE GOING WE NEEDE SUCH GOOD REASEARCH FOR THE MUSIC LOVERS THANKING SOM MUCH FOR U TAKEN EFFORTS SUCEED THIS THANKS11 REGARDS FROM SRI -gERMANY excellent work pl . go on doing some more!1KEE GOING WE NEEDE SUCH GOOD REASEARCH FOR THE MUSIC LOVERS THANKING SOM MUCH FOR U TAKEN EFFORTS SUCEED THIS THANKS11 REGARDS FROM SRI -gERMANY

]]>